MBA - Managing for Sustainability

Subscribe to Free weekly SRI News Alerts

Keyword Search
Find SRI News Articles Related To:

Complete List of Articles by Category

What is RSS?
Add to MyYahoo

Please support our sponsors

Recent News Headlines from

Disney and McDonald's Take Steps to Protect Global Labor (05/13/08)

Proxy Voting Made Painless (05/07/08)

Tracking Suppliers' Carbon Footprints (05/01/08)

Sustainability Investment News Order reprints | Send it to a friend | Print it | Save it  

May 30, 2007

Shareholder Resolutions on Climate Change to Heat Up ExxonMobil's Annual Meeting
    by Anne Moore Odell

A broad coalition of shareholders is seriously concerned about ExxonMobil's lackluster response to global climate change and plans to give thumbs down to board member Michael Boskin. -- Today at ExxonMobil's annual shareholder meeting held in Dallas, an important group of institutional investors plan to vote against returning Michael Boskin to ExxonMobil's (ticker: XOM) board of directors. This decision was made in light of Boskin's refusal to meet with shareholders about the oil company's plans to mitigate climate change. Shareholders will have a chance to vote on shareholder resolutions that call for the company to cut greenhouse gases and to increase their spending on renewable energy sources.

SRI Mutual Funds GuideBoskin is the T.M. Friedman Professor of Economics at Stanford University. He chairs the board's Public Issues Committee, whose role is “to review and provide advice, as the Committee deems appropriate, regarding the Corporation's policies, programs and practices on public issues of significance, including their effects on safety, health and the environment.”

Denise Nappier, Connecticut State Treasurer and principal fiduciary of the Connecticut Retirement Plan and Trust Funds (CRPTF), published an open letter on April 17 that outlined the reasons for CRPTF's withholding of support for Boskin and asked other shareholders to follow suit. The letter reports that five times over the past year and a half a coalition of investors has asked to meet with Boskin to discuss ExxonMobil's position on climate risk. Five times the requests were refused.

“It is ironic that just as ExxonMobil's management finally takes its first cautious steps towards addressing climate change, its directors still fail the basic test of good governance: to demonstrate the board's accountability to the company's owners by engaging with them,” said Karina Litvack, director of governance & sustainable investment at F&C Management. F&C Management is a UK investment manager that owns about 2.6 million shares of ExxonMobil stock.

Investors met with the management of ExxonMobil in July of 2006 to discuss climate change, but the coalition said it would also like to meet with the company's independent directors, of which Boskin is one. ExxonMobil has answered these criticisms of Boskin and reports that Boskin has responded to the group in writing four times and referred investors to Rex Tillerson who is the CEO and board spokesperson on climate change.

The coalition of investors opposing Boskin's reappointment has almost $900 billion of assets under management. They include, among others, California State Teachers Retirement System (CalSTRS), F&C Management Ltd., Illinois State Board of Investment, New York City Employees Retirement System, and New York State Common Retirement Fund. Besides Connecticut, the state treasurers for California, Maine, Maryland, North Carolina and Vermont are voting against Boskin's continuation.

ExxonMobil's annual proxy statement supports Boskin, as do Proxy Governance and Glass Lewis, two independent proxy advisory and voting firms.

Four resolutions on the ExxonMobil's proxy ballet directly address the environment and climate change. Resolution 14 proposed by the Episcopal Church requests the corporation's board report on its accountability for ExxonMobil's environmental impact on communities in which it operates. ExxonMobil's management reports that they already report to shareholders and communities through their “Corporate Citizenship Report.”

One week before today's meeting, ExxonMobil issued their 2006 Corporate Citizenship report that presented the company's economic, environmental, and social performance. The report highlights 2006 achievements made by ExxonMobil including avoiding CO2 emissions of 10.5 million metric tons because of the company's investments is “energy-efficient cogeneration capacity.” The report also includes the company's approach to climate change mitigation.

"This report highlights our continuing commitment to meet the world's energy needs and address environmental and other citizenship challenges-- by producing, refining, and delivering hydrocarbon resources in a responsible manner" said Tillerson. "We are proud of our record of corporate citizenship, and look forward to building upon this record of accomplishment in the future."

A resolution asking ExxonMobil to cut their greenhouse gases was filed by ICCR member the Sisters of St. Dominic from Caldwell, NJ. Resolution 15 asks ExxonMobil's board to support quantitative goals for reducing greenhouse gases (GHG) from its operations and products. It also requests that the company report back to shareholders by September 2007 on its plans.

"This amazing support reflects investors' growing understanding that companies now need to move beyond basic disclosure of greenhouse gas emissions to a business plan to reduce emissions," said Sister Patricia Daly of the Sisters of St. Dominic of Caldwell.

An undisclosed party proposed Resolution 16 that requests customers at gas pumps receive information about the carbon emissions generated by the gas and/or diesel they purchase. No shareholder view was provided for this resolution and management recommends voting against consumer labeling at the pump, because there are too many factors the information would not address.

The last resolution for shareholders to vote on is Resolution 17, asking the company to adopt a policy to increase renewable energy sourcing. The undisclosed party that filed the resolution requests that ExxonMobil work to increase renewable energy sourcing with 15%-25% of its energy sources coming from renewables between 2015-2025. ExxonMobil suggests voting against this resolution and reports that oil and gas remain more profitable than renewables.

ExxonMobil's management proxy statements suggest voting against all four environmental/climate change proposals. The leading agencies that provide proxy voting advice to institutional shareholders, Institutional Shareholder Services, Glass Lewis, and Proxy Governance, are supporting the greenhouse gas resolution. Glass Lewis and Proxy Governance agree with ExxonMobil management on the rest of the environmental proposals.

ExxonMobil is not alone in facing climate change resolutions. The Investor Network on Climate Risk reports that there are 42 global climate change resolutions at US companies this 2007 proxy season. Chervon's proposal regarding global climate change received 9% in their April 25, 2007 meeting. Shareholders, stakeholders and others concerned with climate change and risk mitigation are waiting to see how today's ExxonMobil's votes shake out. Although a company's board need not follow shareholder resolution suggestions, Exxonmobil's board should have already heard the dissatisfaction of some large institutional shareholders who are asking the oil mammoth to work toward a more sustainable future.

© SRI World Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Order reprints | Send it to a friend | Print it | Save it

Related Articles


Mutual Funds | Community Investing | News | Sustainability Reports | Corporate Research | Shareowner Actions | Financial Services | Conferences
Home | Login | Contact | Support This Site | Terms of Use | Privacy Statement | Reprints

© 1998-2008 SRI World Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Created and maintained by
SRI World Group web development services
Do your own research Work with an advisor SRI News SRI Learning Center Home